View Single Post
  #55  
Old September 28th, 2005, 10:14 AM
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default


Amy Blankenship wrote:
Wow. Take a valium. I think everyone following this thread has absorbed
your point, but you can't make everyone agree with you. That's why we have
Democrats and Republicans...because two people can look at the same set of
facts and reach different conclusions based on them. That doesn't make
either side stupid or ignorant. It just means they see things in different
ways.

Why do you care if I care?


Call me a caring person g. It bothers me that people who are
*rightly* considered experts in their field make misstatements which
are taken as 'gospel'.

This is all a bit 'emperor's new clothes' for me as it is. I don't
think prescribing me hypnotics will help, thanks Doctor. "Democrats and
Republicans"? This is a global community, so could you provide a global
analogy, please? In your country, are political commentators considered
sick and/or in need of drugs when they call on politicians to review
their policies when new evidence comes to light?

I think we should be constantly reviewing our advice to ensure it is
the best it can be, especially when we are propagating ideas in public
forum. I'm thinking of the common good, the best for everyone. I've
nothing to gain personally from this; my MVP status surely having been
secured already vbg.

What you are currently using PRIMARY KEY to mean you could replace with
NOT NULL UNIQUE constraints, then you would be free to use PRIMARY KEY
for something more appropriate. PRIMARY KEY may mean other things in
other SQL products but in Access/Jet it means 'super unique index'. Is
it good advice to recommend using your one 'super unique index' for the
table on a single incrementing INTEGER column?

I think the professional response would be, "Clustered index? I didn't
realize that. EITHER I will now alter the advice I give in future. OR
However, after due consideration, I have decided not to alter the
advise I give in future because | I think a monotonic INTEGER makes an
excellent clustered index. | I would be giving different advice from
that of my peers (I've got a reputation to protect). | some other
considered reason.

I don't think "I don't care" is a professional response. I genuinely
respect and thank you for your honesty, though.