View Single Post
  #2  
Old July 3rd, 2009, 02:33 AM posted to microsoft.public.access.tablesdbdesign
tina
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,997
Default One table or Two?

well, you need to analyze your real-world process. will a single instance of
an infraction ever result in more than one consequence being assigned? for
instance, what if detention is assigned, and perhaps started, but not
completed for some reason? and will multiple infractions ever be assigned a
single punishment? you'll know the possible variations best, of course.

once you've defined the situations that the table structure needs to
support, then define the relationship between infractions and consequences:
is it one-to-one, one-to-many, or many-to-many? when you've defined the
relationship, you'll know what table(s) you need to support it.

just a tip: you'll probably want to find a middle ground between what
happens most of the time, and what could *conceiveably* happen. it's not
realistic to build a structure that will support EVERY possible scenario;
but you need to draw the line at the point where you can see a reasonable,
workable way to "squeeze" or "tweak" highly unusual real-world events a bit,
so they fit into the standard parameters you've defined.

hth


"DUNNER7" wrote in message
...

I am progressing with my student database, thanks for all help so far, my
next problem is this. I want to record student discipline infractions.

This
means that I will have a table to record each individual incident as

reported
by a staff member and the table will contain basic info, ie. time,

location,
rule violated, brief description of event. I will probably design a form
based on the table for the staff member to enter each incident. I want

this
information stored into the table and sent to whomever will deal with the
infraction & cc. to me (principal).

Person who deals with the actual consequence/punishment for each

infraction
will have to enter relevant information ie. date, punishement type,

length
of punishment, parent contact made, brief description. This information

has
to be sent back to the referring staff member and stored in a table.

Question is: Do I need two tables? ex. 1: "Violation" and 2:
"Disposition"? Or can I have one table: "Discipline" and each party staff
member and disciplinarian can enter their data piece into the specific
incident on the one (1) table?

If I need two tables the studentID would be the link between the two.

Each
incident and Each disposition would have it own unique number (auto

number)?

Thanks,
Del Dobbs