Excel 2007 -- SUMIFS v SUMPRODUCT

I have had some very useful help from Jacob on an older version of Excel
where he sorted my problem out with SUMPRODUCT (see Problem with Syntax?
posted below):

=SUMPRODUCT(--(TEXT(B2:B20000,"mmyyyy")="012008"),--(C2:C20000="Motor"),(D220000+E2:E20000))

The above formula works great, but I have two questions for Excel 2007 users:
1. If I convert B2:B20000 to B:B, why do I get a #VALUE error
2. Will SUMIFS do the above and if so, how?

Thanks

Hi,
you have to change C , D and E as well, all the ranges in the formula has to
be the same

=SUMPRODUCT(--(TEXT(B:B,"mmyyyy")="012008"),--(C:C="Motor"),(D+E:E))


"MurrayBarn" wrote:

I have had some very useful help from Jacob on an older version of Excel
where he sorted my problem out with SUMPRODUCT (see Problem with Syntax?
posted below):

=SUMPRODUCT(--(TEXT(B2:B20000,"mmyyyy")="012008"),--(C2:C20000="Motor"),(D220000+E2:E20000))

The above formula works great, but I have two questions for Excel 2007 users:
1. If I convert B2:B20000 to B:B, why do I get a #VALUE error
2. Will SUMIFS do the above and if so, how?

Thanks

I tried that already but I get #VALUE error. I dont mind using 20000 but it
is a bit inelegant

Also, will SUMIFS work?






"Eduardo" wrote:

Hi,
you have to change C , D and E as well, all the ranges in the formula has to
be the same

=SUMPRODUCT(--(TEXT(B:B,"mmyyyy")="012008"),--(C:C="Motor"),(D+E:E))


"MurrayBarn" wrote:

I have had some very useful help from Jacob on an older version of Excel
where he sorted my problem out with SUMPRODUCT (see Problem with Syntax?
posted below):

=SUMPRODUCT(--(TEXT(B2:B20000,"mmyyyy")="012008"),--(C2:C20000="Motor"),(D220000+E2:E20000))

The above formula works great, but I have two questions for Excel 2007 users:
1. If I convert B2:B20000 to B:B, why do I get a #VALUE error
2. Will SUMIFS do the above and if so, how?

Thanks

Hi,
That make not sense, formula is OK, please check if in D or E you dont have
any N/A or other error value, as well check that column B is format as text

"MurrayBarn" wrote:

I tried that already but I get #VALUE error. I dont mind using 20000 but it
is a bit inelegant

Also, will SUMIFS work?






"Eduardo" wrote:

Hi,
you have to change C , D and E as well, all the ranges in the formula has to
be the same

=SUMPRODUCT(--(TEXT(B:B,"mmyyyy")="012008"),--(C:C="Motor"),(D+E:E))


"MurrayBarn" wrote:

I have had some very useful help from Jacob on an older version of Excel
where he sorted my problem out with SUMPRODUCT (see Problem with Syntax?
posted below):

=SUMPRODUCT(--(TEXT(B2:B20000,"mmyyyy")="012008"),--(C2:C20000="Motor"),(D220000+E2:E20000))

The above formula works great, but I have two questions for Excel 2007 users:
1. If I convert B2:B20000 to B:B, why do I get a #VALUE error
2. Will SUMIFS do the above and if so, how?

Thanks

Hi

The below links should answer your question 1 (On the limitation)
http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx/kb/166342

On using SUMIFS (this will be helpful)
http://techtites.com/2008/05/22/exce...le-conditions/

If this post helps click Yes
---------------
Jacob Skaria


"MurrayBarn" wrote:

I have had some very useful help from Jacob on an older version of Excel
where he sorted my problem out with SUMPRODUCT (see Problem with Syntax?
posted below):

=SUMPRODUCT(--(TEXT(B2:B20000,"mmyyyy")="012008"),--(C2:C20000="Motor"),(D220000+E2:E20000))

The above formula works great, but I have two questions for Excel 2007 users:
1. If I convert B2:B20000 to B:B, why do I get a #VALUE error
2. Will SUMIFS do the above and if so, how?

Thanks