If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Distribution lists don't show up in BCC when sending
Last week I thought I had finally reached the end of the road with the
migration of a client's Outlook Express address book and groups to Outlook 2003 on a new PC. At every step of the way Outlook would NOT co-operate in setting up the Distribution Lists. Eventually I had to setup a second folder for the original addresses and groups and run Outlook 2003 with 2 PSTs. If I then tried to copy or move the newly imported DLs to rationalise everything it messed up the DLs. Initially the Lists didn't show up in the Address list when creating messages so I had to manually add them. Not a very intuitive default. Finally, I managed to get the Distribution Lists to show up in the BCC line after 3 visists to my client's office. I thought we had reached the end of the road until .................. This morning my client entered his Distribution Lists in the BCC fields of some important mailouts and received this error: "The personal distribution list(s) this message is addressed to must contain recipients. Add at least one recipient to each list." My client verified the DLs were populated by expanding them but received another error: "Cannot perform the requested operation. The command selected is not valid for this recipient. There was an error while expanding the list. The list was not fully expanded." What on earth is going on? I finally managed to get these DLs into Outlook and it still won't do the right thing. Migration between Outlook and Outlook Express is a nightmare if you have to keep DLs intact. When I imported from OE initially not only did Outlook put the items in a folder I did NOT select but it wiped out the OE Addresss Book! Bravo Microsoft! zaphod |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Further details. I created a new test DL in the Contacts folder containing
the imported DLs and it works fine when sent via CC or BCC. zaphod |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Now you see why we recommend against the use of DL's. They are not robust
and rarely survive importing/exporting. -- Russ Valentine [MVP-Outlook] "zaphod" wrote in message ... Last week I thought I had finally reached the end of the road with the migration of a client's Outlook Express address book and groups to Outlook 2003 on a new PC. At every step of the way Outlook would NOT co-operate in setting up the Distribution Lists. Eventually I had to setup a second folder for the original addresses and groups and run Outlook 2003 with 2 PSTs. If I then tried to copy or move the newly imported DLs to rationalise everything it messed up the DLs. Initially the Lists didn't show up in the Address list when creating messages so I had to manually add them. Not a very intuitive default. Finally, I managed to get the Distribution Lists to show up in the BCC line after 3 visists to my client's office. I thought we had reached the end of the road until .................. This morning my client entered his Distribution Lists in the BCC fields of some important mailouts and received this error: "The personal distribution list(s) this message is addressed to must contain recipients. Add at least one recipient to each list." My client verified the DLs were populated by expanding them but received another error: "Cannot perform the requested operation. The command selected is not valid for this recipient. There was an error while expanding the list. The list was not fully expanded." What on earth is going on? I finally managed to get these DLs into Outlook and it still won't do the right thing. Migration between Outlook and Outlook Express is a nightmare if you have to keep DLs intact. When I imported from OE initially not only did Outlook put the items in a folder I did NOT select but it wiped out the OE Addresss Book! Bravo Microsoft! zaphod |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Russ Valentine [MVP-Outlook] wrote:
Now you see why we recommend against the use of DL's. They are not robust and rarely survive importing/exporting. Err, where exactly is this advice documented by Microsoft? I took the advice against importing and exporting the DLs, preferring to copy the original PST from the old machine. (Detail: I originally imported from OE to Outlook on the old PC then copied the PST to the new PC.) From what I have read, when I create a new folder for the PST and point to it via Data Management this should bypass import/export problems with DLs. After much hand-wringing I DID manage to get the DLs into Outlook. Why on earth can't I now USE them? What you are saying seems tantamount to admitting that Outlook, despite its many incarnations, is still beta software? If you "recommend against the use of DL's" what else do you recommend in its place? In Mozilla Thunderbird I can create groups to my heart's content, move them, copy them, import them and export them without a problem. Why can't Outlook do the same considering the financial muscle Microsoft has? Binary format lock-in seems to be coming back to haunt Microsoft. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
I was merely sympathizing with your plight and confirming that these are
well known limitations for which Microsoft has no solutions. These limitations are not documented by Microsoft. They are documented by countless posts to this effect in this and other groups. Groups in OE are not the same as DL's in Outlook and cannot be imported successfully in most cases. Nor can DL's be imported from one version of Outlook to another. Copying the PST file as you did will preserve DL's, but if the DL was first imported from OE it will not work. Most of us gave up on DL's long ago in favor of other ways of groups Contacts such as Categories or separate Contact subfolders. -- Russ Valentine [MVP-Outlook] "zaphod" wrote in message ... Russ Valentine [MVP-Outlook] wrote: Now you see why we recommend against the use of DL's. They are not robust and rarely survive importing/exporting. Err, where exactly is this advice documented by Microsoft? I took the advice against importing and exporting the DLs, preferring to copy the original PST from the old machine. (Detail: I originally imported from OE to Outlook on the old PC then copied the PST to the new PC.) From what I have read, when I create a new folder for the PST and point to it via Data Management this should bypass import/export problems with DLs. After much hand-wringing I DID manage to get the DLs into Outlook. Why on earth can't I now USE them? What you are saying seems tantamount to admitting that Outlook, despite its many incarnations, is still beta software? If you "recommend against the use of DL's" what else do you recommend in its place? In Mozilla Thunderbird I can create groups to my heart's content, move them, copy them, import them and export them without a problem. Why can't Outlook do the same considering the financial muscle Microsoft has? Binary format lock-in seems to be coming back to haunt Microsoft. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Russ Valentine [MVP-Outlook] wrote:
Now you see why we recommend against the use of DL's. They are not robust and rarely survive importing/exporting. So I want to move DLs from Outlook 2003 to Outlook 2003 on a differnt machine I've basically had it? zaphod |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
zaphod wrote:
Last week I thought I had finally reached the end of the road with the migration of a client's Outlook Express address book and groups to Outlook 2003 on a new PC. At every step of the way Outlook would NOT co-operate in setting up the Distribution Lists. Eventually I had to setup a second folder for the original addresses and groups and run Outlook 2003 with 2 PSTs. Why not two contacts folders in the same PST? Finally, I managed to get the Distribution Lists to show up in the BCC line after 3 visists to my client's office. I thought we had reached the end of the road until .................. While DLs in Outlook appear to be fragile at times, they's always behaved well ennough for me unless I did something wrong. What on earth is going on? I finally managed to get these DLs into Outlook and it still won't do the right thing. Migration between Outlook and Outlook Express is a nightmare if you have to keep DLs intact. Well, Outlook Express doesn't have "DLs", it has "Groups". What steps did you take to export the group? I just tested and my OE groups imported as DLs with no problem whatsoever. When I imported from OE initially not only did Outlook put the items in a folder I did NOT select but it wiped out the OE Addresss Book! Bravo Microsoft! That just does not happen with me. Describe the exact steps you used. -- Brian Tillman |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
zaphod wrote:
So I want to move DLs from Outlook 2003 to Outlook 2003 on a differnt machine I've basically had it? Of course not. Just copy (wth Outlook closed) the PST containing the contacts folder in which they reside and open that PST in the other Outlook. -- Brian Tillman |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Brian Tillman wrote:
zaphod wrote: Last week I thought I had finally reached the end of the road with the migration of a client's Outlook Express address book and groups to Outlook 2003 on a new PC. At every step of the way Outlook would NOT co-operate in setting up the Distribution Lists. Eventually I had to setup a second folder for the original addresses and groups and run Outlook 2003 with 2 PSTs. Why not two contacts folders in the same PST? Becaus Outlook would not import the PST from the old PC with DLs intact. Finally, I managed to get the Distribution Lists to show up in the BCC line after 3 visists to my client's office. I thought we had reached the end of the road until .................. While DLs in Outlook appear to be fragile at times, they's always behaved well ennough for me unless I did something wrong. What on earth is going on? I finally managed to get these DLs into Outlook and it still won't do the right thing. Migration between Outlook and Outlook Express is a nightmare if you have to keep DLs intact. Well, Outlook Express doesn't have "DLs", it has "Groups". What steps did you take to export the group? I just tested and my OE groups imported as DLs with no problem whatsoever. Exporting from OE doesn't work if you want the groups intact so I had to setup Outlook on the old PC to be able to import directly into Outlook using the Import tool. When I imported from OE initially not only did Outlook put the items in a folder I did NOT select but it wiped out the OE Addresss Book! Bravo Microsoft! That just does not happen with me. Describe the exact steps you used. 1. Install Outlook 2003 on the old PC which has OE groups. 2. Create new Contacts subfolder within Outlook called "Backup" so that I can move existing Contact items there and free Contacts for the incoming OE items. 3. In Outlook move items from Contacts to Backup 4. In Outlook go to File Import Import Internet Mail & Addresses Outlook Express 4.x, 5.x, 6.x 5. Select Import Address Book 6. Replace duplicates with items imported 7. Finish At this point the dialogue assures me that "Addresses will be imported into your Outlook Contact Folder". Fine in theory. Here's what happened: 1. A dialogue box told me 0 addresses had been imported 2. All addresses and groups were wiped out of Outlook Express At this point I was convinced I had destroyed my client's business address book. 3. Outlook had imported the OE addresses and groups but put them in the new Backup folder I later discovered (to my relief/annoyance). 4. Outlook had given me the wrong message about not importig any addresses successfully. So, for an hour Outlook convinced me that not only had it wiped the OE Address book but it hadn't imported anything at all. Explain that one, Microsoft. When I discovered the addresses and groups had been imported I quickly made a backup and tried exporting to a PST file. This failed to keep the DLs intact so I resorted to creating a second Personal Folder in Outlook on the new PC, copied the system PST from the old PC and added it via Data File Management. The DLs now appeared intact within the new folder but when composing a message they didn't appear in the Accounts list so I had to manually instruct them to be included (nice default, Microsoft!). I thought my problems were over but now, when I attempt to rationlise the 2 Personal Folders by moving the items from the new folder to the original folder I hit a problem. When everything has been moved and the folder is removed the imported DLs no longer contain any items! When I restore the deleted Personal Folder they reappear ... within the OTHER Personal Folder. All I can say is I'm glad I had the good sense many years ago to ditch Outlook and go with Mozilla Mail. The nonesense that is going on with groups/DLs between Outlook and Outlook Express beggars belief. Aren't you ashamed to be working for a convicted monopolist who charges over £400 for an office suite that can't even guarantee that a user's DLs/groups will remain intact when backups are performed? With all its $billions are you telling me that Microsoft cannot program such a simple task as maintaining lists of email addresses without such complication and unreliability after so many incarnations of Outlook? |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
You made life a lot harder than it needed to be. You could have used
file, open, outlook data file and opened the pst, not imported it. Then drag the DL to the new pst. You also could have copied the wab to the new machine and hooked OE to it - then tried the import. It's much easier than installing outlook and moving the pst from machine to machine. -- Diane Poremsky [MVP - Outlook] Author, Teach Yourself Outlook 2003 in 24 Hours Coauthor, OneNote 2003 for Windows (Visual QuickStart Guide) Author, Google and Other Search Engines (Visual QuickStart Guide) Outlook Tips: http://www.outlook-tips.net/ Outlook & Exchange Solutions Center: http://www.slipstick.com Join OneNote Tips mailing list: http://www.onenote-tips.net/ "zaphod" wrote in message ... Brian Tillman wrote: zaphod wrote: Last week I thought I had finally reached the end of the road with the migration of a client's Outlook Express address book and groups to Outlook 2003 on a new PC. At every step of the way Outlook would NOT co-operate in setting up the Distribution Lists. Eventually I had to setup a second folder for the original addresses and groups and run Outlook 2003 with 2 PSTs. Why not two contacts folders in the same PST? Becaus Outlook would not import the PST from the old PC with DLs intact. Finally, I managed to get the Distribution Lists to show up in the BCC line after 3 visists to my client's office. I thought we had reached the end of the road until .................. While DLs in Outlook appear to be fragile at times, they's always behaved well ennough for me unless I did something wrong. What on earth is going on? I finally managed to get these DLs into Outlook and it still won't do the right thing. Migration between Outlook and Outlook Express is a nightmare if you have to keep DLs intact. Well, Outlook Express doesn't have "DLs", it has "Groups". What steps did you take to export the group? I just tested and my OE groups imported as DLs with no problem whatsoever. Exporting from OE doesn't work if you want the groups intact so I had to setup Outlook on the old PC to be able to import directly into Outlook using the Import tool. When I imported from OE initially not only did Outlook put the items in a folder I did NOT select but it wiped out the OE Addresss Book! Bravo Microsoft! That just does not happen with me. Describe the exact steps you used. 1. Install Outlook 2003 on the old PC which has OE groups. 2. Create new Contacts subfolder within Outlook called "Backup" so that I can move existing Contact items there and free Contacts for the incoming OE items. 3. In Outlook move items from Contacts to Backup 4. In Outlook go to File Import Import Internet Mail & Addresses Outlook Express 4.x, 5.x, 6.x 5. Select Import Address Book 6. Replace duplicates with items imported 7. Finish At this point the dialogue assures me that "Addresses will be imported into your Outlook Contact Folder". Fine in theory. Here's what happened: 1. A dialogue box told me 0 addresses had been imported 2. All addresses and groups were wiped out of Outlook Express At this point I was convinced I had destroyed my client's business address book. 3. Outlook had imported the OE addresses and groups but put them in the new Backup folder I later discovered (to my relief/annoyance). 4. Outlook had given me the wrong message about not importig any addresses successfully. So, for an hour Outlook convinced me that not only had it wiped the OE Address book but it hadn't imported anything at all. Explain that one, Microsoft. When I discovered the addresses and groups had been imported I quickly made a backup and tried exporting to a PST file. This failed to keep the DLs intact so I resorted to creating a second Personal Folder in Outlook on the new PC, copied the system PST from the old PC and added it via Data File Management. The DLs now appeared intact within the new folder but when composing a message they didn't appear in the Accounts list so I had to manually instruct them to be included (nice default, Microsoft!). I thought my problems were over but now, when I attempt to rationlise the 2 Personal Folders by moving the items from the new folder to the original folder I hit a problem. When everything has been moved and the folder is removed the imported DLs no longer contain any items! When I restore the deleted Personal Folder they reappear ... within the OTHER Personal Folder. All I can say is I'm glad I had the good sense many years ago to ditch Outlook and go with Mozilla Mail. The nonesense that is going on with groups/DLs between Outlook and Outlook Express beggars belief. Aren't you ashamed to be working for a convicted monopolist who charges over £400 for an office suite that can't even guarantee that a user's DLs/groups will remain intact when backups are performed? With all its $billions are you telling me that Microsoft cannot program such a simple task as maintaining lists of email addresses without such complication and unreliability after so many incarnations of Outlook? |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Create a distribution list using other distribution lists | lc | Contacts | 1 | August 29th, 2005 07:37 PM |
Copying distribution lists | Joseph McGuire | Contacts | 2 | April 27th, 2005 07:48 AM |
Do Distribution Lists automatically update as Contacts change? | spencergb | Contacts | 3 | January 10th, 2005 08:11 PM |
Distribution Lists | Contacts | 1 | August 19th, 2004 10:31 PM | |
'Distribution Lists' versus 'Personal Distribution Lists' | Pete The Oz | General Discussion | 10 | July 18th, 2004 05:56 PM |